Commercial real estate has created tremendous wealth for investors over the years, but it has also humbled many who underestimated the risks. In today’s higher interest rate environment, successful investing isn’t just about finding the next great opportunity. It’s about avoiding the wrong ones.

In a recent episode of the Build It to Billions Podcast, Brett Swarts sat down with John Azar, Founder and Managing Partner of Peak 15 Capital, to discuss the biggest mistakes investors make and the three red flags that should never be ignored before investing in a commercial real estate deal.

If you’re considering investing passively in multifamily, industrial, self-storage, or other commercial assets, these insights could help protect your capital.

Red Flag #1: Inexperienced Operators

According to John Azar, the most important factor in any commercial real estate investment isn’t necessarily the property. It’s the people behind it.

Many sponsors know how to acquire deals during booming markets. Far fewer know how to operate those properties through economic downturns, rising expenses, and changing market conditions.

The difference between buying an asset and successfully managing it over several years is enormous.

When evaluating an investment opportunity, ask questions like:

  • Has this operator successfully managed similar properties?
  • Have they navigated difficult market cycles before?
  • Do they have experience in this specific market and asset class?

As Brett points out, today’s commercial real estate environment has exposed many operators who only experienced years of low interest rates, rapid rent growth, and favorable financing. Those conditions no longer exist, making operational experience more valuable than ever.

Red Flag #2: Unrealistic Underwriting Assumptions

One of the biggest contributors to today’s distressed commercial real estate market has been overly optimistic projections.

John explains that many deals completed in 2022 and 2023 relied on assumptions that simply didn’t materialize.

Common examples include:

  • Annual rent growth in the double digits
  • Unrealistically low operating expenses
  • Overly aggressive appreciation projections
  • Heavy leverage with optimistic refinancing assumptions

These assumptions created attractive projected returns on paper, but not necessarily in reality.

Instead of focusing only on projected IRRs or equity multiples, investors should dig deeper into how those numbers are generated.

Ask sponsors questions such as:

  • What rent growth assumptions are being used?
  • How are insurance and property taxes projected?
  • What vacancy assumptions are included?
  • How conservative is the underwriting?

John shared that Peak 15 Capital often assumes zero rent growth during the first year of underwriting to build in a margin of safety. That conservative approach may not generate flashy projections, but it helps prepare for conditions in the real world.

Red Flag #3: Misaligned Timelines and Incentives

Every investor has different liquidity needs.

Some expect their capital back within two years, while others can comfortably invest for five to eight years.

John cautions investors to understand the expected holding period before committing capital. Commercial real estate investments frequently take longer than originally projected, particularly during challenging markets.

Equally important is ensuring the sponsor has meaningful “skin in the game.”

If a sponsor recovers all of their invested capital through acquisition fees or other upfront compensation at closing, their incentives may no longer be fully aligned with investors.

The best sponsors continue to have meaningful capital invested alongside their investors, creating shared risk and shared reward throughout the investment lifecycle.

As Brett notes, the goal isn’t necessarily to create a structure that’s simply “fair.” It’s to build an equitable partnership where everyone’s incentives remain aligned for success over the long term.

Bonus Tip: Know the Market

Even an experienced operator can struggle in an unfamiliar market.

John encourages investors to spend time understanding the local market before investing. Look at population trends, employment growth, rental demand, and economic drivers.

Better yet, invest with sponsors who have a proven track record operating in that specific geographic region, rather than just commercial real estate experience in general.

Final Thoughts

Commercial real estate continues to present outstanding opportunities, but disciplined investing has never been more important.

Before investing in your next deal, remember these three essential questions:

  • Does the operator have proven experience through multiple market cycles?
  • Are the underwriting assumptions realistic and conservative?
  • Are the sponsor’s incentives aligned with yours for the long term?

Markets will always change. Strong operators, disciplined underwriting, and aligned partnerships are what help investors preserve and grow wealth regardless of the economic cycle.

Looking to Defer Capital Gains Before Your Next Investment?

If you’re selling appreciated real estate, a business, cryptocurrency, or another highly appreciated asset, having a tax strategy before closing can significantly increase the capital available for reinvestment.

The Deferred Sales Trust may allow qualified sellers to defer capital gains taxes, increase liquidity, diversify investments, and invest into opportunities such as commercial real estate without many of the limitations associated with a traditional 1031 exchange.

Schedule a complimentary consultation with the Capital Gains Tax Solutions team to learn whether a Deferred Sales Trust fits your exit strategy and start building your customized Capital Gains Tax Exit Plan before your sale closes.

Share This